Showing posts with label Murfin Memoir.. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Murfin Memoir.. Show all posts

Saturday, August 15, 2020

Shopping With Mom in Cheyenne Taught an Unexpected Moral Lesson

The clipping that jarred a memory.

It didn’t take much to jar the memory.  Stored long ago and jammed tightly in the closet of a dusty recess of my mind, it fell to the floor and rolled to my feet when shaken by a mild tremor.  I picked it, popped the twine, and peeled back the layers of yellowed newsprint that had wrapped it.  There it was.  60 some odd years old and only somewhat dinged and nicked, a small part snapped off here and there,  but whole and hefty in my hands.
What shook it loose was of photo posted on a Facebook page for nostalgic old denizens of Cheyenne, Wyoming, the place where I grew up.  It was a .jpeg of a newspaper clipping with the grainy image of a building and a story under the headline, DDA Aims to Purchase Z’s Furniture Building.  The caption noted that the building once was home to Fowler’s, Cheyenne’s leading department store back when they were putting fins on Chevys.  The article explained that the building had been vacant and a home to pigeons for some years and that the Downtown Development Association hoped to buy it and somehow turn it into “a mixed residential and commercial use anchor” for what has evidently become a moribund business district.  Little cared I for that, but Fowlers….
Fowlers sat at the corner of 17th and Carey in the heart of what was at the cusp of the ’50’s and ‘60’s a bustling downtown shopping district.  Like most of the downtown, the building had been erected in the boom years of the 1880’s when the Union Pacific Railway yards and the cattle business made the Wyoming Territorial Capital a bustling and progressive place—the city Tom Edison picked to install his first street lighting, forward thinking and modern shaking the mud and shame from its boots for its wild days as Hell on Wheels.
In that spirit the Fowlers, the family that owned the department store had itself gone mid-century modern.  They clad the upper three stories of the building in gleaming white, windowless and smooth masonry and wrapped the first floor in sweeping display windows worthy of anything in New York or Chicago.  The name Fowler’s was emblazoned against those white walls in a bold but flowing script at a jaunty rising angle.  It stood out proudly, different than anything that surrounded it.
Fowler’s, you see, was our Macy’s, our Marshal Fields, our May Co.  It was where  the better class of matrons—and those like my mother who desperately wanted to join their ranks—of Cheyenne, half the state, and much of western Nebraska came to find the latest fashions straight from New York and where their husbands bought their double breasted suits and had them marked with chalk and fitted by real tailors.

16th Street in downtown Cheyenne circa 1960.  One block over on 17th Street Fowler's Department Store sat a the corner of Carey Avenue.
There were, of course, other department stores down town.  There was Montgomery Ward and J. C. Penney, and a couple of smaller, less prestigious, local owned places.  There were ladies dress shops, men’s wear places, shoe stores, and of course Western Ranchman Outfitters where everyone went to get their cowboy on.  Mom shopped at them all, dragging me and my twin brother Tim along with her on her weekly Saturday expeditions.  Most weeks we looked, or she ended up just picking up notions at Woolworth’s.  But a few times a year it was serious shopping—back to school time in August, the Christmas rush, and the time to get us all polished up for Easter.
For our back to school jeans and plaid shirts, Ward’s and Penney’s would do.  She would have to shop for my jeans in the Husky boys department, a mild humiliation especially when she would chat loudly with the sales women, most of whom she seemed to know from the PTA, Cub Scouts, church, or various charity projects, about my failure to firm up into a suitably athletic young man.  We would buy a pile of three or four jeans to last the year.  Mom would count her bills out to the clerk who would put them with a ticket into a brass and glass capsule and send them shooting off through mysterious pneumatic tubes  to some distant office and after a few moments her change and receipt would come zooming back.
To get ready for Frontier Days or to shop for my father who’s job at the Wyoming Travel Commission required him to be turned out in cowboy style, it was off to Western Ranchman where Tim and I could get our annual pearl snap shirts, silk kerchiefs, cowboy boots, and dress straw hats, none of which were to be worn except for rodeo events and state occasions decreed by Mom.

Dad, W.M. Murfin (center) cowboying it up at Western Ranchman Outfitters

But for her own wardrobe and for our Sunday-go-to-meeting dress clothes, nothing would do but Fowler’s.  This particular Saturday, it must have been in October or November because there was a sense of urgency, the mission was to get me a winter coat.  And not just any winter coat, a very particular one. 
Tim, the all-American boy and apple of my mother’s eye, had already laid early claim of teenage style.  He was carefully smoothing his dark hair with generous glops of Brylcreem every morning which left it shining and immovable and insisted on being shod, at least until the snow flew, not in boots or polished lace-up shoes, but in black and white high lace-up PF Flyers.  He had overwhelmed mom’s early objections and picked out a letterman style jacket with leather sleeves and wool body that he would wear in all but blizzard conditions.
I, on the hand, was pursuing my single minded desire to dress like a 40 year old so that I would be treated with respect.  The fact that the gray Rough Rider style hat with the pinned up side brim that I was habitually wearing in those days belied that ambition evidently escaped me.  The hat embarrassed Mom no end, but she could not get it off me until it was cold enough for my black leather cap with the fold down earflaps and chin strap.
Other than my hat, my mother approved my middle age style aspirations, although she approved of very little else about her bookish son.  In her mind that was classy, the most vaunted ambition of a woman who had grown up dirt poor and who yearned for middle class respectability.  So the coat for which we were searching was a good wool car coat, the kind that could fit over a sport coat but was not quite a full overcoat.  Most importantly it must have a fur collar, and a least a suitable faux fur one.  This had turned out to be a difficult quest because, surprise, surprise, most stores were not showing coats like that for pre-teen boys.  But if anyone in town would have it, it had to be Fowlers.
Just before we descended into the boy’s department in the basement Mom took my brother and I to the side and shook us strongly by our shoulders so, along with a certain terrifying steely tone to her voice, told us that she meant business, and bent down low to whisper in our ears “I don’t want you to say a word about Mr. Brown.  Do you understand?”  Brown was not the real name which is lost to my memory or an alias created to spare embarrassment to any surviving family, but a mere generic substitute.
One morning over breakfast before school a week or so earlier, mom had gasped loudly and laid down her coffee cup.  “Murf!” she said to my father, her head enveloped in the usual cloud of cigarette smoke, “Did you see this?  The paper says that Ed Brown was arrested in the men’s room of the Wyo Theater the other day on a morals charge!  And I always thought he was such a nice man.” 
The Wyo was one of three downtown movie houses.  The Lincoln was the top, the one that got most of the biggest films and hosted the road shows for Biblical Epics like The Robe or Ben Hur, the Paramount showed double bills with A picture tops.  But the Wyo showed B movie triple bills, horror and sci-fi, the cheaper oaters.  That’s where you went to see a flick in 3D—if you mother would let you, which ours did not.  But once in a while we would sneak over there, ditching the Saturday marathon kiddie matinee at the Lincoln where we had been deposited, to see something thrilling like Attack of the Fifty Foot Woman.  The washrooms there were dirty and had sticky floors, but I had no idea of what sort of crime could be committed in them.
I was unclear on what a morals charge was or why anyone would get arrested in a toilet.  My more sophisticated brother informed me that it meant that Brown was a queer, although he was hazy on what exactly that meant except that it was dirty.
Later that day after school Mom ever so casually asked us if Mr. Brown had ever touched us, “down there” when we were at the store.  The question confused me.  She tried to explain and got red faced.  Finally I semi-understood.  “No,” I said, “not even when he measured me for pants.”

17th Street looking West from Capital Avenue in the mid-50's.  We did most of our back to school shopping a Montgomery Ward's, the red brick building on the left, across the street from the Wyoming Tribune building.  Fowler's was up the street to the right in the multi-story building seen here before it was clad in the new white façade.  
Back at Fowlers, Mom released us having given her most impressive fair warning.  We descended the stairs to the brightly lit Boy’s Department.  Almost as soon as my mother’s foot touched the floor, Mr. Brown rushed over to greet us with a broad smile as if he were encountering long lost kin.  I guessed him to be about my Fathers age, but that meant he could have been anywhere from 30 to 50.  He had close cropped rather curly hair with just a hint of gray.  He wore those glasses with a tortoise shell top frame and gold rims securing the lenses.  Was there a moustache? My memory is hazy, but let’s give him a close clipped thin one.  He wore a subdued hunter’s plaid sport coat, crisp white shirt with a bow tie, sharply pleated slacks and gleaming oxfords. 
“Mrs. Murfin!” he exclaimed, “How is Murf?”  They fell to chatting excitedly sharing family details.  Mr. Brown was married and had children evidently around our age who went to a different school.  His wife was going to model for Fowlers at an up-coming charity fashion luncheon at the Palomino Club out on the highway to Denver.  It went on like that for a while my brother and I fidgeted.
Eventually Mom broached the purpose of the expedition.  Mr. Brown turned and considered me.  I was wearing that damn Rough Rider hat and last year’s zipper fall jacket, too tight now with frayed knit cuffs riding high above my wrists and a rip in one of the slash pockets from shoving a balled up glove into it with too much force.  Clearly I was a boy in need of counseling and clothing. 
“Hmm,” he said after consideration, “I have just the thing.”  He rifled through some racks and pulled out a light brown car coat of wool so soft, he said, it might as well be camel’s hair.  It had three large leather buttons, commodious pockets and, yes, a fine faux fur brown collar.  I put it on and stood in bay of three mirrors to examine myself as Mom and Mr. Brown hovered behind.  “It’s a little big,” I said noting that the sleeves half covered my singers when I hung my arms to my sides.  Mom nodded silently.
“But look how tall Pat is getting!”  I tried to stretch myself taller, proud of my one advantage over my brother.  “He’ll grow into this by Christmas, just you see.” 
Mom nodded again. “We’ll take it.”
I took off the coat and handed it to Mr. Brown.  We all strolled together back to the register.  On the way Brown casually whipped the Rough Rider hat of my head, snapped up a brown fedora on the way past, and sat it on me at a jaunty angle.  “What a handsome young man!” No one ever had called me handsome in my entire life and may not have ever complimented me on my looks.  That was Tim’s personal department.
Mom turned to carefully survey me.  She picked up the hat, weighed the possibility that I could be convinced to wear it instead of my battered old hat.  I more than half wanted her to buy it, but dared not say so.  She looked at the price tag and then, somewhat sadly, returned it to the mannequin head from which Brown had snatched.
By the register Brown carefully folded my new coat and laid it in a large white box lined with tissue paper which he carefully folded over it and smoothed down with a practiced hand.  He carefully fitted the top on and then from a large cone of twine on a spindle tied the package with speed and ease.  Mom handed over a ten dollar bill and got back little change.  I may not have ever had such an expensive garment. 
All the while Mom and Mr. Brown chatted, smiles beaming from both.  After extended pleasantries Mr. Brown shook my mother’s hand and turned and shook mine with a dry, firm grip as if I was important and grown up.  I carried the large package for my Mom.

Rodel's Drug Store was west of Fowler's and was a frequent stop on our Saturday shopping sprees for treats at the soda bar.  We spent too much money on my coat to stop on this trip.
On the walk back to the car she told us that we had spent so much money that we would have to skip the usual stop for sodas at Rodell’s Drugs.  She had a worried look.  I knew with some guilt that she had wildly over spent and was concerned about what to tell Dad.
We climbed into Mom’s ’51 Chevy, Tim as usual riding shotgun in the place of honor in the front seat.  I sat behind Mom with the package stretched out beside me on the seat.  Mom lit up an unfiltered Kool and the car was soon filled with a haze.  On our drive back to the house on Cheshire Drive, I worked up the courage to ask what Mr. Brown could possibly have done to get arrested.

More than a year later, at Christmas 1961, I was still wearing the car coat,  Note it was getting a little tight. With twin brother Tim in his cool letterman style jacket and our dog, Fritz on our front step on Cheshire Drive.
After a pause Mom said, “Some people just don’t know to keep out other people’s private business.  You’d think the Police Department would have better things to do than hiding out in a men’s room stall.”  And that is all she would say on the subject.  We drove home the rest of the way in silence.
We continued to see Mr. Brown at Fowler’s until I entered high school and started getting my clothes in the Men’s Wear Department.
Later I realized that a small article like the one about Mr. Fowler was enough to drive some men from town in disgrace.  I learned of other men who were fired from their jobs, whose wives left them, and at least one who was beaten to a pulp outside a bar.  But the Fowlers, a very nice couple, treated all of their employees “like family.”  Mr. Brown had been with them for years and was very good at his job.  In those days a man could make a not extravagant but comfortable middle class living as a commission floor salesman at a Department store.   No matter what private conversation they may have had with him, they were loyal to Mr. Brown and even left him in the Boy’s Department instead of exiling him to some position where he would never come in contact with us.  That had to cost them customers.
And then there was Mom.  I may have learned more from her about kindness and compassion that day than in all of the Sunday school classes that she ever sent me to.

Monday, May 4, 2020

The Not So Golden Anniversary of Kent State and Murfin Memoirs of the Days Following

Ohio National Guardmen take aim on retreating student demonstrators on the Kent State campus.  Note the officer with the pistol who may have given an order or signal to tire.
Fifty years ago today on May 4, 1970 Ohio National Guard troops opened fire on student anti-war demonstrators on the very middle American campus of Kent State University.  Four students were killed by the gunfire—Jeffrey Miller, Allison Krause, William Schroeder, and Sandra Scheuer.  Only Miller was an active participant in the protests that day, Krause and Scheuer were sympathetic bystanders, and Schroeder was a totally non-involved ROTC student killed at a distance while walking from a class.  Nine other students were injured.  No Guardsman was seriously injured.  
The Guardsmen were said to have fired spontaneously in fear of being attacked by the demonstrators.  But film evidence shows the demonstrators were retreating and more than a 100 yards down a slope from the troops.  There is also now considerable evidence that an officer with a pistol ordered or signaled a command to fire.
John Filo's Pulitzer Prize-winning photograph of 15 year-old Florida runaway Mary Ann Vecchio kneeling over the body of Jeffrey Miller. 
Full accounts of the shootings, the days of unrest prior to the fatal afternoon, the aftermath, and the investigations can be found in several online sources including author William A. Gordon’s website in support of his book Four Dead In Ohio: Was There a Conspiracy at Kent State?; the Kent May 4 Center, an off-campus resource; Kent State’s own May 4, 50th Commemoration site; and the handy and generally reliable Wikipedia entry.
There are also official Ohio State and FBI investigations that must be taken with tablespoon-fulls of salt.  Among the scores of books I still recommend the very readable Kent State: What Happened and Why by novelist James A. Michener which was rushed to publication in 1971.  Without the considerable evidence later uncovered, Michener concluded that the shooting was a “tragic accident.”  But the book is excellent in putting a human face on the participants and victims and especially in disclosing the raw generational divide in the aftermath that had one survivor being told by his parents that he should have been shot.  Some of those family rifts, not only at Kent State but around the country between demonstrators and their silent majority parents have still not healed and there were grandparents who never met their grandchildren and now aging adult children who were never welcome at their parents’ funerals.

The paperback edition of James A. Michener's early book on the tragedy.
The Kent State killings and the murders of Black Jackson State University in Mississippi were an outgrowth of a May 4th national Student Strike against the war.  In the wake of the Kent State massacre that strike blossomed into hundreds of demonstrations all over the United States including university occupations, pitched street battles, and mass demonstrations that continued for more than a week.  

A poster for the May 4th student strike against the invasion of Cambodia and on-going War in Vietnam.
Despite the spasm of rage and militancy, student anti-war activism subsided considerably over the next two or three years.  Leadership of a mass anti-war movement shifted to the respectable middle class and efforts like the Vietnam Moratorium.  Ohio Governor James Rhodes and President Richard Nixon were both convinced that the shootings successfully broke the back of student radical activism.  More recently Donald Trump hinted that similar “very rough treatment” would solve the problems of Black Lives Matter and Native American anti-pipeline protesters.

The Official Kent State University commemoration logo.

There would have been elaborate commemorations today at Kent State, which now takes pains to honor the victims, but those fell victim to the Coronavirus pandemic lock down.  Instead several events including a virtual candle light vigil, a noon Eastern Daylight Time ceremony, and exhibits and panel discussions will stream at and be made available on YouTube.
For many of my generation Kent State and its aftermath were central life altering events in our lives.  What follows is an account of my own small part in those events, as best as my poor memory can reconstruct things 50 years later.
My Own Private Kent State 

I must have been at my brother Tim’s (later known as Peter) apartment on Sheridan Road near the Morse Ave. Beach when we got the news of the shooting.  Oddly, unlike other Great Events, I can’t fix in my mind the moment I heard the news. 

Rather than hopping on the L to get to my own school, Columbia College, a small communications college located on a few floors of a commercial building at Grand Ave. and the Inner Drive north of the Loop, my brother convinced me to go with him and his friends to his campus, Kendall College in Evanston.  Kendall was then a small, private two year college mostly drawing students from the northern suburbs.  Neither the school nor my brother was particularly politically active.  Tim was the center of acid dropping spirituality and the self-appointed guru to a circle of acolytes, many of them fellow students at Kendall.  He said he left the Revolution to me. When we arrived on campus, students were in full possession of the buildings and the administration was nowhere to be found, although some faculty was on hand mingling with the students.  There was no police presence; it was as though the administration had simply abandoned the school to the students. 

Students rallied on the Northwestern campus.  The night of May 4 they erupted onto Sheridan Road and erected barricades that stayed in place for days.  Some students from near-by Kendall College went over to join them.
Some folks had gone over to join Northwestern students at barricades erected on Sheridan Road.  Others milled about trying to figure out what to do.  One student was working a Ham Radio and gathering information from actions at campuses across the country.  We soon realized that this could become an asset.  
Phone connections were somehow made with students from campuses across the Chicago area and we fed them news gleaned from the Ham operator.  Not all of that information was reliable, some turned out to be wild rumor, but enough was good so that it became apparent that we were part of a spontaneous nationwide student uprising that was growing by the hour.  
Besides participating in the phone network, I started posting the news on large sheets of paper, updated regularly throughout the night to keep students informed.  I called them the Joe Hill Memorial Wall Posters and had about a dozen of them lining hallways by the time the night was over.  
There were also informal discussions all night.  I was considered a real live activist because of my connections with the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW) and my input was probably given more credence than I deserved.  By morning I had agreed to return to campus later and set up some educational programs, which I did do, although Kendall never became a hot bed of radicalism.
In the morning, running on adrenalin, I headed down to Columbia.  Columbia was a commuter school specializing in communications and the arts—broadcasting, photography, theater, dance, and writing.  With no one living on our non-existent campus, I was not sure what I would find.  There were no classes but it wasn’t exactly a strike either because the administration was totally supportive of the student cause and offered the facilities of the school free to the movement.  
I headed down to the print shop in the basement, where I worked as one of two printers.  We ginned up our little A.B. Dick 360 and Multilith 1250 offset presses and were soon turning out hundreds, even thousands of flyers, posters, handbills, and other material advertising actions across the city and region.  

This banner hanging from an occupied campus building somewhere in America summarized the mood of outrage and defiance that swept campuses.
I have no recollection of how, but I was selected as one of two representatives from Columbia to a city wide student strike committee.  I believe it was Wednesday when a couple of hundred folks met at the Riviera Theater in Uptown to plan coordinated actions.  
The meeting was a perfect example of sometimes chaotic participatory democracy, but a consensus was arrived at to have a unified, city wide march and demonstration downtown on Saturday.  I was named to the demonstration organizing committee with students from University of Illinois Circle Campus, University of Chicago, and Roosevelt, among other schools.  Many of the others members were in SDS.  Others were Trotskyites, who made something of a specialty of organizing big demonstrations.  There was a sprinkling of Anarchists as well.  But the ideological wars that wracked campuses were suspended—mostly—in the face of the common emergency.  Another meeting the following day was held at Circle Campus.
Again, I have no memory of how, but I was selected to try and negotiate with Chicago Police in what most felt was the vain hope of avoid an attack by authorities the day of the March.  Given the background of the Police Riots against demonstrators during the 1968 Democratic Convention, at protest marches connected to the trial of the Chicago 7, and the virtual street warfare around the Days of Rage in October ’69 there was little reason to hope for a better outcome.
Late Thursday afternoon I was escorted through an eerily quiet Police Headquarters to the office of Deputy Superintendent James Riordan.  I believe I may have been taken through a route intended to keep rank and file police from seeing that the brass was meeting “the enemy.”  Riordan was cordial.  We shook hands.  We both clearly understood the potential volatility of the situation.  I told him that organizers intended an entirely peaceful march and pointed to some earlier mass marches that had gone off without a hitch.  I also pointed out that there had been no significant acts of violence on any of the Chicago area campuses even at Northwestern with its barricades or the building occupations at other schools.  I said that we would have marshals to keep our demonstrators in line and moving and to discourage break away marches.  Although others were trying to obtain a parade permit, I said that we intended to exercise our free speech rights and march with or without one.  
 Riordan said he understood and said that the police did not want to provoke a confrontation and would be as “restrained as possible.”  I told him that we expected police would line the rout of march, but that putting those officers in full riot gear or having them stand with batons conspicuously exposed might be provocative under the circumstances.  Riordan made no explicit promises but indicated that if we kept our people in line there would be a kind of truce.  I got the distinct impression that higher-ups had already decided to try to avoid more bad national press.

A peaceful Kent State student strike march much like the one in Chicago.
All during this period, although I was known to be a Wobbly, I was not acting in any way as a representative of the union.  I did inform the Chicago Branch of developments and the branch decided to participate in the march.  That Saturday rather than joining other “leaders”—and I use that term in the loosest possible manner—in the front of the march or joining with Columbia or Kendall college contingents, I marched as a rank-and-file member of the IWW behind our black and red banner.  Although riot equipped police were on hand, they were kept largely out of sight.  Officers lining the route wore standard blouses and soft caps.  Their batons were kept under their coats.  The march and rally went off without a serious hitch or any violence, which is more than can be said of marches in other cities.
Later, I reported on the events in the pages of the Industrial Worker.