The story with the dramatic headline is a few years old and based on research on religion in America on even older data collected by the Pew Research Center in 2014 and additional studies by conservative religious think tanks, but it floats now and again on social media as Halloween rolls around again. Depending on your perspective the news was shocking, appalling, or an encouraging sign of a broadening of America spirituality.
Of course, the Pew Center never made the claim that there are now more witches than Presbyterians—journalists extrapolated the claim because it made an eye-catching headline and guaranteed clickbait. Then pundits and bloggers ran with the story giving it their own spin. The original research simply noted that Wicca, the largest new-pagan group had exploded with claimed adherents. From 1990 to 2008, Trinity College in Connecticut ran three large, detailed religion surveys that showed Wicca grew tremendously from an estimated 8,000 in 1990, to about 340,000 practitioners in 2008.
Eight years later Pew found that there were about 1.5 million people identifying as Wiccan, but that many, if not most of these did not belong to any coven or claim to be solo practitioners. Most of the rest might best be described as spiritual seekers attracted to the mythology, connection to the Earth and environment, and to a female-centric religion but who do not seriously practice Wiccan rituals.
The Pew study also noted a general decline in both membership and identification with Christian churches both Protestant and Catholic even including Evangelicals who had showed sharp growth in the previous two decades. Mainline Protestant denominations showed the steepest declines.
Sifting through Pew’s count of membership by denomination, reporters noted that claimed Wiccan adherents outnumbered the enrolled membership of the Presbyterian Church (USA), the largest Presbyterian denomination in America but does not include the membership of more than a half dozen small Presbyterian bodies who cleave to the rigid Calvinism of their Scottish roots or the many who profess to be Presbyterians out of family attachment but do not belong to any church and infrequently worship.
So not only do the headlines mislead—taken all together, there are still more U.S. Presbyterians than Wiccans—but compares apples to oranges. Unlike Christian denominations, Wiccans with an amorphous and de-centralized structure, keep few if any membership records beyond individual covens, and have few buildings of their own. Self-defined adherents can’t be usefully equated with solid membership data. According to a 2016 Gallup Poll, 2% of Americans self-identify as Presbyterian—about 6.6 million or 5 times as many Wiccans
Presbyterians trace their origins to the Protestant Reformation in the mid-16th Century from the theology of John Calvin via Scotland’s John Knox and spread to some English Dissenters. They came to America with 18th Century Scottish, English, and especially Scotch-Irish immigrants. They became a major force in the Middle Colonies and were the original religion of the Scotch-Irish who led pioneer settlement throughout the trans-Allegany West and South. Like their cousins, the Congregationalists of New England, they prized a highly educated clergy who were loath to follow their frontier settlers into primitive conditions. Most of the Scotch-Irish except for a landed elite drifted away to the Methodists with their lay preachers and saddle bag circuit riders or to the Baptists whose congregations freely ordained their own ministers with little formal training.
During and after the American Revolution, many Northern and urban Presbyterian ministers also became influenced by the Scottish Enlightenment which was also a leading influence on many of this country’s founders. That began a long, slow but steady shucking of much Calvinist doctrine. These Presbyterians became influenced by the Social Gospel movement. By the post-World War II era the largest Presbyterian denominations were mostly liberal and cultural progressives. Demographically they were considered a faith of the educated and elite right behind the Episcopalians and alongside the Congregationalists who became the United Church of Christ.
The PC(USA) was established by the 1983 merger of the Presbyterian Church in the United States, whose churches were located in the Southern and Border States, with the United Presbyterian Church in the United States of America, whose congregations could be found in every state. It has shed most vestiges of Calvinism except for its unique governance and polity. Since then, social issues including the ordination of women and LGBTQ+ status within the denomination, disinvestment in South Africa to protest apartheid, and harsh criticism of Israeli abuse of Palestinian rights led to some member churches to leave the denomination and individuals to resign membership or simply fade away. Undaunted, the PC(USA) remains committed to social justice.
I think of our friends from the Ridgefield-Crystal Lake Presbyterian Church who are Tree of Life UU Congregation (TOLUUC) allies, collaborators, and now hosts whose members were long active in the local McHenry County Peace movement, actively engage in hands-on support for the poor and oppressed in Central America, and have a vigorous environmental ministry. They are now cooperatively sharing their facilities with TOLUUC and the McHenry County Jewish Congregation.
Despite claims to deep roots in pre-Christian Celtic or Druid practice, Wicca is much younger. It was created in its present form by Gerald Gardner, an English civil servant and amateur anthropologist who died in 1964 who was influenced by Masonic ritual and occult lore to hang an elaborate structure on the barely understood elements of an ancient culture.
In America that was greatly elaborated on and popularized by The Spiral Dance: A Rebirth of the Ancient Religion of the Great Goddess; a book by the poet and mystic Miriam Simos known as Starhawk. The book was widely influential well beyond the still small and idiosyncratic world of neo-paganism. It was avidly read by feminists, those interested in deep ecology, and women in small towns and cities who had felt isolated and alone.
Starhawk was an early and influentially active member of the Covenant of Unitarian Universalist Pagans (CUUPS). Her influence contributed heavily to the adoption of the Unitarian Universalist Association’s Seventh Principle, “Respect for the Interdependent Web of All Existence of Which We Are a Part” in 1983, a move led by the faith’s growing eco-feminist movement. That inclusion has in many ways profoundly changed traditional Unitarian Universalism broadening its roots form radical Christianity and modern Humanism, influencing the way the faith acts in the world, and being a major catalyst for a revival of spirituality in the liberal faith.
When the history of religion and spirituality in the late 20th Century America is written it is possible that the most influential person might not be some mega-church pastor with a perfect pompadour and dazzling white smile, a learned theologian with a break-out idea, a prelate or president of some denomination, or the guru of some eastern mysticism, but Starhawk a nice Jewish girl from St. Paul, Minnesota with wild hair and a penchant for colorful flowing robes.
Most of Wicca’s adherents realize that the creation of Gardner and Starhawk is not a literally accurate re-creation of an ancient religion. It doesn’t matter. The mythology surrounding any religion is equally questionable. What is important is how that mythology usefully informs an understanding about the world, humanity, and morality. While some practicing Wiccans may believe they are actually invoking real gods and spirits in their rituals and incantations, the vast majority do not. They understand the power of metaphor.
Modern Wiccans have generally been successful in separating their brand of witchcraft from Satanism except among the most conservative Christians. Many are now attracted to a faith that proclaims a wholesome connection to nature, the cycle of the seasons, and the divine feminine.
That’s a trend that is apt to continue as more and more Americans describe themselves as “spiritual but not religious.” But don’t worry, the Presbyterians will still be around.
