Showing posts with label political purists. Show all posts
Showing posts with label political purists. Show all posts

Sunday, January 27, 2019

A 2012 State of the Union Post Still Relevant

Barack Obama's 2012 State of the Union Address.

Note—On this date in 2012 I reviewed President Barack Obama’s State of the Union Address.  While generally positive it was far from a rave.  Much of what I wrote back then is not only still relevant and some of it was prophetic.  The oligarchic far right did indeed come to power behind Man on a White Horse—Donald Trump and indeed has been busy dismantling every protection for working people, the poor, minorities, and the environment.  But that coup was enabled in no small part by those on the left who demanded political purity and sat out or outright sabotaged a candidate who although far from perfect could have prevented the current catastrophe. Now despite the apparent evil in power and despite the success of the Blue Wave in the last election, there are new rumblings and vows to take their toys home if an absolutely perfect candidate of their choice winds the 2020 nomination.  We need to learn from the past.  

The other night after the State of the Union Address I posted this as my status update on Facebook:
You don’t have to agree with the President on everything to realize that he gave a masterful, galvanizing speech. He touched all of the right emotional notes, wrapped himself a bit in the flag, put forth a mostly and unapologetically progressive program and painted it in positive terms, not as negative reactions to Republican pettiness. He reminded everyone that he is the most gifted orator in the White House in generations. Coming a day after another Republican loon fest broadcast on national TV and before a wooden, lame, and negative response from an obscure governor that the NBC political reporters openly swooned for in contrast to actual Republican candidates, he just won back the wavering middle while shoring up the support of disenchanted liberals. A pretty good night's work, I'd say.

I knew what I was in for.  I got a lot of likes from friends who are Democrats, liberals, and loyal Obama fans.  I also got one scold from a fervent supporter of the Occupy Movement who wrote, “Turn off your televisions. Ignore the Newt-Mitt-Rick-Barack reality show. It is as relevant to your life as the gossip on Jersey Shore,” and provided me with a link to stronger stuff.  Those sentiments were echoed by posts from several good friends, committed radicals each and every one.

Some of those loyal Democrats have in the past wondered at my steadfast support of the Occupy movement, and suggested that the movement was unfocussed, counterproductive, and that it diverted energy from the “real task” of electing progressives to set things right.  You know the rhetoric, you’ve probably read it.

Both sides want to know, with some urgency, how I can reconcile being a fire breathing radical and open advocate of direct action and a proud old Wobbly on one hand, with being a plodding, loyal down-in-the-trenches Democratic functionary—a McHenry County Dem Precinct Representative—who will vote and work for the re-election of the President and for other party candidates.  I contradict myself.  Of course I do.  In the words of Walt Whitman:

Do I contradict myself?
Very well then I contradict myself,
(I am large, I contain multitudes.)

Or consider my favorite quote from Ralph Waldo Emerson, “Consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds.”

But there is some method to my apparent blatant hypocrisy and ideological apostasy.  I am both an idealist and activist and a practical politician because I know how to play offense and defense.

On offense, I have long advocated for uniting in an open and aggressive assertion of our rights and demands.  Elections in which no fundamental change is possible because we are locked into a two-party system representing factions of the same system are not enough, although not unimportant (see below for more on that.)  Organizations like unions which have traditionally been the enablers of common struggle are more and more constrained by law and legalisms and marginalized as “pleading special interests.”  The press and mainstream media are unanimously in the hands of defenders of the status quo of some type or another and cannot be relied upon to “crusade” in our behalf.  The avenues of traditional dissent—petitioning, local demonstrations and pickets, vigils, and even annual mega marches on Washington that draw hundreds of thousands of participants can and are ignored by that media because they are “old news.” The militarization of police in this country coupled with the unlimited capacity for electronic surveillance and monitoring of every aspect of our lives effectively deters much more forceful protest.  But happily not all.

I have advocated agile, new forms of organization unencumbered by either charismatic or bureaucratic leadership which can quickly reflect and implement the demands of the people.  This is something that the unleashing of modern electronic communications—e-mail, social media, blogging, advanced cell phone capacities including special apps and instant sharing of photos and videos—has made possible as never before.
 
Thousands mobilized in Madison through a bitter Wisconsin winter to protest Gov. Scott Walker's attacks on working people begining a new wave of mass protest.

What I wrote in 2008 in connections with re-inventing the labor movement hold true for the even broader movement we have seen emerge from the protests in Wisconsin and the Occupy Movement:

The shape of what it [a re-invented labor movement] will look like is only beginning to emerge.  But it will certainly come out of the knowledge that the traditional labor movement has bound itself to near impotency by accepting the restrictions of American labor law in exchange for the scraps of a supposedly “sympathetic” NLRB and the ease of collecting dues by check-off deductions from wages.  New organizations may pointedly not call themselves unions or engage in direct bargaining with specific employers for contract defined benefits just so they can be free of the straight jacket the traditional unions have put on themselves.  They will take advantage of modern technology and instant communications.  Organizations like MoveOn have shown that, with the right spark unimaginable numbers of people can be linked together and organized for common purpose in amazingly short periods of time.  And organizations of this type are apt to be loose, flexible, independent of massive bank accounts that can be seized at any time, and resistant to top-down leadership…I place my faith in the future in the hands of the dawning self-awareness of the new working class and its creativity.  May it ever be so.
Also critical is the reawakening of a sense of social solidarity which had seemed crushed out of existence for decades in this country.  The Occupy movement with its insistence that we are all the 99% united against the greed and arrogance of the oligarchy of the 1%.  Writing in a Labor Day sermon, The Working Class Virtue of Solidarity in 2009, I put it this way:

Solidarity is the response of the week and marginalized to overwhelming power.  Individuals learn that no act of their own can truly change their condition of oppression and exploitation.  Those in power have the means, and an overwhelming motive, for ruthlessly slapping down any one who dare pop up in opposition.  But members of oppressed class come to realize one simple truth:  They can’t kill all of us.  Not only that, they discover that together they represent a resource without which the exploiters cannot continue to reap wealth and benefits.  Their power lies in both their number and in the dependence of the powerful on them.

The power of this kind of solidarity when taken to the streets has been shown over and over again since the People Power revolution against the Marcos regime in the Philippines two decades ago, to the wave color coded revolutions that brought down one after another the repressive Communist oligarchies of the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe, to the mass anti-austerity protests that began to erupt in Western Europe last year, to the thrilling and unexpected sweep of the Arab Spring.

As the United States sank into an economic collapse of its own and faced millions being forced into poverty and the collapse of the middle class dream, the question on the world’s lips was “where are the Americans?”  The Americans, in fact, were restrained by a number of factors, not the least of which was the illusion of democracy and the hope that the crisis was just another unfortunate blip and that prosperity would return.

After months, then years, it became apparent that there would be no return to the old, comfortable “normal.”  And apparent that the Republican zealots and tools of the most powerful members of the ruling oligarchy who were swept into power by a misguided throw-all-the-bums-out protest vote were determined to launch an all-out assault on the working and middle classes.

The spark that lit the powder keg, of course, was the loud mouth arrogance of Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker.  In the blink of an eye thousands were on the grounds of the capital in Madison and stayed there through brutal winter weather.  Protests spread around the states.  Newly elected Republican governors in other states advancing the same bought-and-paid-for agendas found themselves with other uprisings.

Then came that Arab Spring.  This time American working people were paying attention.  They were asking, “Why not us?”  It was a question I asked at a public meeting in support of Wisconsin workers in Woodstock last April.  It was time to take to the streets as never before, not in orchestrated marches and carefully controlled rallies, but in the face of the oppressors and would-be oppressors.

The Adbusters simple graphic call that launched a mass movement.

The Occupy Movement sprang from a mere suggestion, a nice graphic poster from an obscure Canadian magazine published by ideological anarchists—note not the street fighting anarchists known for their violent disruption of international gatherings—and the power of social media to spread the word.  It struggled at first and was dismissed as a ragged handful in a New York park.  But with astonishing quickness, it spread.  Hundreds of thousands joined as local Occupy movements sprang up around the country and around the globe.

It was spontaneous, yet it was disciplined.  Through the use of regular Assemblies and the rejection of titled leaders or charismatic spokespersons it honed a message.  And it developed a strategy—mass peaceful protest and willingness to engage in mass civil disobedience.  It has stayed remarkably true to both the form of organization and its strategy.  Despite massive repression and the constant danger of provocateurs and plants attempting paint the movement as violent, it has only grown and its influence has spread.

Occupy Wall Street and the local Occupy camps and protests around the county was an example of the working class reinventing their organs and institutions.
 
This is exactly what I meant about the “working class re-inventing” their organs and organizations.

The Occupy movement has survived a harsh winter and the loss of many, probably most, of their camp bases.  It has adapted, found new ways to express itself, and is poised with the coming of spring to re-emerge on the streets as a mass presence.

And despite every attempt to discredit it or ignore it, the Occupy movement has shifted the American political conversation.  A year ago class inequality and the power of the economic elites over every aspect of our lives were not even issues that registered in any polling.  Today they are front and center of the national debate.  Demands across the board for ending corporate personhood, attacking income inequality, and protecting the vulnerable among us have picked up steam.  Politicians notice and begin to echo popular sentiments.  Poll after poll shows that most Americans broadly agree with the goals of the Occupy movement.

This is an offense that works.  Keep it up I say.

On the other hand there is defense.  The right wing has not been asleep.  They have their own well-funded  pseudo populist movement—the Tea Party—to counter the rise of the left.  They also have managed to achieve almost unlimited control of government at every level due to protest voting in the last election and sit-on-their-hands discouragement of progressives.  Only the Presidency, the Senate, a minority of Governors and state legislatures, and some big city mayors stand between them and total control—a control which they would never cede again in truly free elections.  The billionaires who bankrolled the Tea Party and bought the Republican Party out right are prepared to spend unlimited sums to complete their triumph.

They are also counting on a disaffected left to make it possible.

Despite the rhetoric of Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Dum that we hear so regularly from some of the left, there is a difference—a huge difference—between Republican and Democrats on a wide range of issues.  If you think things are bad now, wait until the Right gets total control and strips away, one after another, every social program that stand between families and hunger, every guarantee of a modicum of work place dignity, every regulation that stands between your pocket and legalized pick pocketing, equal rights for every despised minority including the majority minority, women, any environmental protections that may prevent global catastrophe, rewards its religious allies with a virtual theocracy on “moral” issues, and belligerently threatens anyone in the world who doesn’t go along with the program.

Look, I know that Democrats are often spineless in Congress.  I know that many of them are on the take from powerful interests.  I am not blinded to Obama faults and deficiencies.  I will join you in protest to all of that.  No reason to let Democrats get away with crap just because they are Democrats.

But let me put this as bluntly as I can—if you think there is no difference between the two parties you are just plain crazy. If you think a boycott of elections will “get their attention” you are delusional. If you think that allowing the Republicans to win to “clarify the class relationships and force the people into rebellion” you are psychopathic. 

This 2016 anti-Clinton meme--milder than many--was an example of the pick-up-my-toys-and-go-home mindset of the purist left.  The results were predictably disastrous although the guilty will point fingers at everyone else and bleat pathetically when called to account.  And now we know that many of these attacks were generated by Russian bots and trolls and eagerly spread.  The same forces are at work again.

And no, given the structure of our political system and the time frame to the next election a third or fourth party like the Greens, an illusionary Labor Party, or and knight-in-shining-armor independent presidential candidate are not valid options.  All that any such efforts can do is make the heart of the Grinch smile.

The Kotch brothers and all of their friends hope and pray you are so pissed off that you stay home.  It reduces the number of votes they have to steel or buy and saves them the trouble of trying to strip you of your vote via their voter suppression schemes.  I say, if you want to do their bidding, you might as well take their money.

As bad as things are, they can be ten times worse in no time.  So I will work, vigorously, for the re-election of the President and for Democrats up and down the ticket.  That’s playing defense.

There is no reason to abandon either an offense or a defense despite what you hear from the purists of one side or another.

Saturday, September 5, 2015

Endorsing Bernie Sanders—Time to Ante Up

Bernie Sanders from unlikely outsider long shot to serious contender.


Back in March of 2007 when this blog was a toddler and read by dozens over at LiveJounal it—and that means me—officially endorsed Barack Obama for the Democratic Presidential nomination as soon as he made his official announcement in Springfield.  Not that it meant a good God damn but it would give me bragging rights for hopping on the bandwagon when it was still a pony cart and Obama was still an upstart with a funny sounding name not well known to most Democrats.
Of course coming from Illinois made it easier.  I had met and chatted with Obama in the dust of Illinois State Fair when he was still an obscure State Senator and just beginning to consider a run for the U.S. Senate.  I remember being tremendously impressed but walking away telling myself that a guy with a name like that could never be elected state wide.  Two years later I was shown never to underestimate him as he swept aside primary rivals and mopped the floor with the GOP’s laughing stock last minute imported candidate Alan Keyes.  I saw him several times at modest sized campaign events and later as Senator at a town hall meeting at the Woodstock Opera House.  I concluded never again to underestimate the man.

In 2007 I jumped in with both feet for Barack Obama as soon as he made his formal announcement of his candidacy at the Old State Capitol in Springfield.


I recognized Obama as opponent of the War in Iraq—one of the few to vote against a free hand for George W. Bush—and a solid progressive who also had a knack for working practically with political opponents.  He was also the most spectacularly gifted orator to seek the Presidency since Lincoln.  Despite a long and often bitter primary slug fest against Hillary Clinton, the media’s presumed inevitability, and a general election campaign against an allegedly straight shooting maverick Obama swept to a stunning triumph in 2008.
I have to admit that election was one of the most emotional and personally satisfying moments of my life.
Obama would sometimes disappoint me.  I am at odds with him issues like the use of drones, continued support for the national security and surveillance state, coziness to Wall Street, and recently approval of Arctic drilling permits.  On the other hand, he inherited an unprecedented national economic emergency and dealt through most of his presidency with a rabidly obstructionist Republican Congress.  He often ran rings around his Congressional enemies most often blocking their most disastrous, reactionary, and racist plans.  They could do little but sputter and bluster.  He even managed to push through a far-from perfect Health Care plan which none-the-less made insurance and affordable health care available to millions and laugh off constant attempts to repeal or defund it.  He stood up to government shutdown blackmail and in his second term, oddly liberated by being a lame duck, accomplished a laundry list of impressive progressive achievement.  The most vilified president since Lincoln, Obama is on track to being recognized as greatest President since Lyndon Johnson—a man who also had a mixed legacy.
It is much later in the interminably long Presidential campaign season this year than when I endorsed Obama in 2007.  Yet I have sat on my hands.  Perhaps because I retired last year from my long run as McHenry County Democratic Precinct Representative, I have not tried my hand at political punditry.  I’ve been out of the game. 
Although she played coy, Hillary Clinton long considered to have a lock on the nomination if she wanted it and was widely believed to be unbeatable against any of the possible midget clowns the Republicans could throw against her.  I said so myself repeatedly in both electronic print and in innumerable private conversations.  Yet left Democratic activists and many progressive independents were dissatisfied with the former Secretary of State as relative hawk and a corporate Democrat with deep to Wall Street.
I watch the almost ecstatic boom for Senator Elizabeth Warren, the blunt spoken foe of the Big Banks and for sweeping economic reforms.  But Warren was having none of it, even as the internet and social media was ablaze with a Draft Warren movement.  I lost track of how many times she had to flatly declare that she wouldn’t run before here disappointed supporters finally believed her.
Only then did they turn, somewhat reluctantly, to Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders, who was best known as the eccentric white haired coot who was elected as an independent and only caucused with Congressional Democrats.  He was said to be, openly and unapologetically, a socialist and was secular Jew and a former radical activist.  Has anyone so patently un-electable made a serious run at the Democratic nomination since, well, Barack Obama?
Sanders quickly won over the skeptical Warrenites by echoing her stand on the Banks and on growing income inequality.  He impressed them with a series of YouTube videos in which he sat down and directly addressed the camera to forthrightly present his views and concrete proposals on a wide range of issues dear to the Progressive hearts.  Then with little money or campaign organization Sanders hit the hustings.  Soon he was drawing record breaking crowds in places like Madison, Wisconsin; Portland, Oregon; Des Moines, Iowa; and even in the heart of red state Dixie from Texas and Alabama to North Carolina.  Small donors began to flood the campaign coffers of the man who eschewed contributions from big money PACs,
Through the spring and summer the media ignored the rising tide for Sanders.  When he surged to a lead in New Hampshire, traditional make or break first Primary state and began closing the gap on Clinton in Iowa, the first caucus state and Clinton seemed vulnerable to the constant Republican smear campaign yodeling the old Benghazi aria and mixing in the tempest-in-a-tea-pot non-scandal about here use of a private e-mail account, the TV talking heads and op-ed denizens finally began to take notice.  Of course they only did so to knock him down as an un-electable extremist.
One quickly picked up meme in the media echo chamber yoked Sanders to Donald Trump, of all people, as two sides of inarticulate populist rage.  That allowed them to ignore Sanders’s detailed policy proposals and equating them with Trump’s pandering sloganeering.

Hillary Clinton, long the presumptive nominee, enjoys solid support among self identified Democrats and devoted followings among Feminists and in the Black community.
Sanders’s rise and Clinton perceived vulnerability—more perception than fact as she maintains a commanding lead with hard core Democratic primary voters—encourage long shot candidacies by former Republican and Connecticut Governor Lincoln Chafee, Maryland Governor Martin O’Malley, and conservative Democrat and former Virginia Senator Jim Webb.  None of them stands a chance unless Clinton drops dead or is found sleeping with Donald Trump.  More seriously Vice President Joe Biden is making serious noises about running and could drain some of Hillary’s establishment support and be available as a compromise candidate in the event of a deadlocked convention, a scenario that is often talked/dreamed about but which has not happened since John W. Davis won the worthless Democratic nomination in 1924 after 103 ballots.
Clinton’s campaign problems are obvious, but likely not insurmountable.  Sanders, as her main competition faces his own problems beyond pointed media bias against him.  Despite a strong Civil Rights background, including dangerous stints with SNCC in the South, leading Chicago housing discrimination sit-ins, and a 100% NAACP voting record rating in Congress, Sanders has not connected strongly to Black voters who by in large are extremely loyal to Clinton.  Part of that seems to be due to living so long in Vermont, one of the Whitest states in the nations.  When a large Portland rally was disrupted by two protestors somewhat tenuously connected to the Black Lives Movement did image among Black voters, not even subsequent supportive statements by others in the movement could quickly undo the damage.
That hurts, but may not be insurmountable as he gets his message more clearly out and spends more time in Black communities.  Overcoming his own gender gap may be harder.  It seems like Sanders is the overwhelming favorite of white male progressives, a demographic that while sometimes energetic and often loud has never carried an election anywhere.  A lot of women like and support him, of course, but a whole lot of feminists are devoted to Clinton who has shown over and over in her long career that she is one of them.  They are the ones that fueled her long hold-out in the 2008 run-up to the Democratic National Convention when it was clear to almost everybody that Obama had sewn up the nomination.  A handful never forgave Obama and sat out the election, other never worked up full enthusiasm for him.  No matter that Sanders’s record on women’s issues, like Obama’s is nearly spotless.  Elizabeth Warren might have been able to peel away significant support from these women.  Sanders will have a much tougher time.
A very smart and sophisticated woman who is a facebook friend likes Sanders and his positions, but in her mind, continuing to break the grip of White privilege and patriarchy on the presidency that began with Obama, trumps all other considerations.  In some ways it is a compelling argument and one that resonates with many Black and other minority voters as well.

Things like this reflect the deep passion of Sanders's core constituency.
But Sanders’s biggest problem might be in the hard core of his deepest supporters.  They tend to be ideological purists and have little stomach for compromise or for any variation from a virtual progressive party line.  This may be related to the testosterone problem noted above.  Some of these folk quickly abandoned Obama in his first term for seeking compromise with the Republicans in Congress, not recognizing how sophisticated his game plan war.  Or they dumped him because he would not hold out for a universal single payer health plan, over pipelines and drilling, domestic surveillance, you-pick-your-pet issue, and in droves over drones.  If Sanders veers off course on any issue or show insufficient rigor the partisans of that issue will turn on him as well.
Worse are those who are already declaring that they can never support Clinton or anyone else who might win the nomination.  They already jump righteously on those who circulate social media memes promising to support whoever gets the Democratic nomination.  Some counter with their own meme vowing to write in Sanders if he doesn’t get the nomination or who will simply sit out the election if that is the case.  This attitude rightly offends actual Democrats as opposed to movement activists especially since Sanders’s ties to the party whose nomination he is seeking.  It also alarms a lot of sensible folk who worry that such navel gazing purity could be enough to hand the Presidency to some extremist Republican clown in a close election.  And those folks are not reassured by hearing the purest of the pure dismiss that concern because a GOP victory in such circumstances would clarify the contradictions and somehow speed more revolutionary change.  You actually hear this kind of bullshit tossed around by some on progressive sites like the Daily Koz.
Then there is the lingering question of Sanders’s electability.  I think there is a path for Sanders to win the nomination and the General Election, but it is narrow and tricky.  Virtually everything has to fall in place just so to make it happen—a rare event in politics.  So no matter how much momentum he has right now, he still has to be considered a long shot.
Yet his candidacy has invigorated the campaign which would otherwise simply be a prolonged coronation.  He has brought America’s most critical issues into sharp focus and is the only candidate in either major party with detailed proposals to fix what is ailing in this country.  He has already forced Clinton to the left, perhaps not as unwillingly as some suspect—you may recall that in 2008 many regarded her as more progressive and liberal than Obama on all but the anti-war issue.  He has reshaped the debate in Congressional races and certainly will impact the party platform.
And then there is the nagging thought that maybe, just maybe, if we hold our tongues just right in our mouths and balance on one foot on one foot he really can win.
In the end it comes down to whether now is the time to vote for what I really want or cast my practical lot with what I can settle for.  

Woodstock Square, the Old Court House, and Jail, site of a Labor Day Celebration sponsored by Sanders Volunteers/
Since I have been invited to address the Labor Day Celebration in Woodstock Square this Monday from 11 am to 2 pm which is sponsored by local Sanders volunteers, I suppose this is as good a time as any to shit or get off the pot.
Guess I will poop out a full throated endorsement of the candidate who more closely mirrors my own beliefs and positions than any other in my life time.  Heretic, Rebel, a Thing to Flout and I both declare for Bernie Sanders for whatever it is worth and pledge to work for his nomination and election.
But I also pledge to support the ultimate Democratic nominee, whoever that is.