These folks wanted their First Amendment Freedom of Speech in Chancellorsville.
Note—Six years ago after the violent confrontations in
Charlottesville I posted a re-evaluation of an even older post from way back in
2012. It seems the issue never goes
away. In fact it has intensified
reflecting the hardening divisions within society, evidenced by the July 6,
2021 insurrection at the Capitol, another bitter election season, and the
passions exposed by protests about the Israeli devastation of Gaza. If my opinion on First Amendment absolutism
drew fire back in 2012 it will probably be.
What’s the beef? First Amendment absolutism. Below is the original 2012 post as edited for present reality and my evolved
opinion.
Every writer, whether he wishes
to admit it or not, occasionally commits a turn of phrase that seems to him so
perfect that he just has to stand
back to admire it. I came up with one of my personal such favorites more
than thirty years ago in a letter
describing a particularly obstreperous fellow worker: “He’s such
a flaming asshole that he can’t sit down without igniting the furniture.”
Not Shakespeare perhaps, but
certainly a classic insult. The
events in Charlottesville and the reaction to it are just the most recent things that have brought this back
to mind.
There are certainly no greater
flaming assholes than the collection
of knuckle dragging turds, neo-Nazis,
Klansmen, White Nationalists, and Alt-right
prep boys who organized the Unite
the Right events in Charlottesville.
The gathering was ostensibly a protest
of the planned removal of
a monument to Robert E. Lee which they said was an attack on their heritage. The rally and the
inflammatory speeches that would be
given there, and the display of Confederate Battle Flags,
Nazi and fascist banners and emblems, and Ku Klux Klan regalia was also painted as an expression of their First Amendment Rights to freedom of speech and assembly which they claimed were under attack by a liberal/communist/Jewish conspiracy.
Naturally there were calls for the City to deny permits for hate speech and ban the demonstrations, especially communities who were not only the targets of the expected hate speech but
had historically suffered violence and oppression at the hands of those who followed the same ideologies and symbols—Blacks,
Jews, immigrants, and the LGBTQ+
community.
The city understood that the assembly and speech, as dangerous and offensive was
it was protected under the First Amendment to the Constitution. It was well
settled law that expression,
especially political speech, cannot be used as the basis for denying permits. But there
seemed to be precedent for placing certain restriction on protest gatherings in the interest of public safety. On that basis the city denied a permit to
gather at the small Emancipation Park—formerly
Robert E. Lee Park—and instead offered
space in a much larger city park just a few blocks away where the Unite the
Right Rally could also be physically
separated from the thousands of counter demonstrators expected. Many, including the local press, business community, and traditional civil rights organizations, thought that this was both sensible and reasonable.
It is true that such restrictions
have become common. It is also true that
the left has been far more
frequently the target of them than even the most menacing and often
armed displays of than the right. Think of the so-called caged free-speech zones now routinely set up blocks from
national political party conventions,
campaign events, appearances by the President, and major
international gatherings economic and summit
gatherings. On
the other hand abortion clinic patients and
staff have been sheltered from aggressive anti-abortion protestors by safety or protective zones that allow clear
access to the facilities.

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) has always opposed those restrictions regardless of content of the speech or the politics of the protestors. So it
was no surprise that they took the case of Unite the Right and
challenged the city’s refusal to issue permits for Emancipation Park. They argued that their client’s rights were
violated because the statue in the
park was the issue they were addressing.
The court agreed and issued a late, emergency order to the city to grant use of Emancipation Park.
The ACLU
was promptly on everybody’s shit list and denounced
in often
heated terms by the city, press, and irate anti-racists. There were some noisy and high profile
membership resignations and fundraising
boycotts being organized on social
media in the blink of an eye. ACLU lawyers and
officers were harassed and received death threats. But then everyone
gets death threats these days for saying
anything more controversial than good morning. It’s the modern American way.
In 1977 the ACLU secured the right of the notorious Illinois Nazis to
march in heavily Jewish Skokie, Illinois, home to many Holocaust
survivors.
Of course just months earlier the ACLU
was the darling of the same pack of dogs were then snapping at their heels.
When the Cheeto in Charge came
to power the ACLU was everywhere pissing
on dozens of constitutional arson
fires set by the feckless President. In short order they blocked every attempt to instate his Muslim ban, protected immigrants, staved
off attacks on LGBT rights, parried
assaults on voting rights to
name just a few examples. Folks were so grateful than in the early months of the new administration the ACLU racked up tens of thousands of new
members and unexpected millions of dollars in financial contributions.
It should have come as no surprise, however.
The ACLU shed members like a mangy dog’s fur when they helped the Illinois Nazis obtain a permit to march in the Chicago suburb of Skokie, a heavily Jewish
community with many Holocaust
survivors back in 1977. They have
always taken cases regardless of the
content of the speech under attack including case involving such despicable
outfits as the Klan and the violent
anti-abortion group Operation Rescue.
Of course the reality on the street was that a violent confrontation between the
White Nationalists and their opponents was inevitable. Could it have been limited if the two sides were pent
up and separated by ranks of militarized police with shield, batons, gas, and rubber bullets? Perhaps.
Or the situation could have degenerated
into a three way brawl. But it was a done deal when authorities closed
the park after scuffling broke out and forced both sides into the streets and then stood back and let them go at it.
Heather
Heyer’s death cannot be, as one left wing critic wrote, “laid on the altar of free speech fetishism”
nor was the ACLU her assassin.
The violence in Charlottesville was
not the only one recent example of folks on one side or another of our great political, moral, and ethical divide trying
to shut down the speech of their foes. Without elaboration the list includes:
·
Campus
groups demanding the firing of professors, banning
of speakers, banning other
campus organizations, or censoring
student publications—by both sides.
·
Moves in Congress and several state
legislatures to actually criminalize advocacy for a boycott of Israeli businesses and products as
inherently anti-Semitic
·
Moves in several state legislatures to make blocking highways—a common protest method of the Black Lives Matter movement—a felony and giving legal protection to
drivers who ram protestors.
·
So-called Religious Freedom laws that
give an out to businesses and
even individual public officials
who refuse to serve Gays, lesbians, and
transgender folk or even those who advocate for them.
·
Gag orders with heavy
penalties for public officials who speak out about the Trump administration’s dismantling of environmental, health, and safety regulation and
the stripping of science information
from government web sites and
publications.
·
Nearly continuous demands to block or ban social network content for an ever growing laundry list of reasons.
And that only scratches the surface.
After much consideration, I have to come down on the side of the
god-given right to be an asshole.
Everyone is somebody else’s asshole—at
least everyone with the requisite
combination of strong opinions and backbone. That means that there is
always someone out there that yearns to
shut us up and someone we want to muzzle in turn. In
my case small armies would like
to slap the gag on me. There was the sputtering “Let’s turn Iraq to a sea of glass” guy who denounced my namby-pamby treason at an anti-war vigil a few years ago. There
are the anonymous phone callers
every time I wrote a letter to the
editor in support of marriage equality. There are the proper Catholic ladies who hissed “baby killer” at me when I used to work
at the Democratic Party booth at the
County Fair. Any vague mention of
gun violence most reliably resulted in threats to me
and my family. My support of Black Lives Matter sends internet trolls into ferocious
rages. I could go on, but you get
the picture. Almost any one of these folks would be overjoyed to have the
government arrange for either my
silence or disappearance.

I, of course, have my own list of knuckle dragging buffoons,
crackpots, and hate spewing bigots who I am sure need the deft application of
a dirty gym sock shoved far down offending throats.
In the end my cherished right to be obnoxious to some folk depends
on having to put up with the offensive
speech of others. I do not trust any government to make a call
on what is permitted or not. In this sense I am a First Amendment absolutist in this country and fervent defender of free speech everywhere in the globe.
But that does not mean any asshole
has to be “tolerated” in the sense
of being allowed to
proceed unchallenged or outrage unchecked
by the public. The best part of free speech is our to his absolute right to call an
asshole an asshole to his face and hold him up to ridicule and scorn. The truism is that the best
weapon against a bad idea is a better one.
The voices and feet of 40,000 people like this, not the power of the
state, shut down a Ku Klux Klan rally in the heart of Boston. Note the
UU Standing on the Side of Love folks in their yellow gear in the front
of this photo.
We have seen this in action in the literally thousands of vigils and marches that spontaneously
arose after the Charlottesville spectacle. The planned Klan rally in Boston was
a prime example. Neither the City or State tried to shut it
down, nor indeed authorities were bound to
protect the rights of the racists. But 40,000 took to the streets to oppose
them, dwarfing the few dozen who
showed up, keeping most of the self-proclaimed leaders away, and ending the event hours
earlier. Our side’s free speech, our people power, was more effective than
any official action. And in the
aftermath 35 planned hate events in other cities were canceled by their
sponsors.
But even the ACLU had second thoughts after
Charlottesville. They were especially
responsive to complaints by members and supporters that they had enabled the hate groups to menace counter demonstrators with semi-automatic military style
weapons. That was a more than implied threat of lethal violence. The group’s executive director announced that the ACLU would no longer
represent groups who planned to deploy arms in their demonstrations. Free speech does not protect that kind of physical threat, especially a threat used to stifle the speech of
others. The ACLU made a wise call
without undermining their most solid traditional commitments to
Constitutional liberty. And I completely concur.
Armed Militia thugs are not exercising their First Amendment
Rights--they are threatening and intimidating those who are using the
right and inevitably such displays will lead to mass bloodshed. The
line is drawn here.
Meanwhile I’ll continue to resist attempts by the government to pick and choose speech it approves of. History has taught me that my
ox is more likely to be gored by that than the other guys.
But don’t be shocked if I someday punch a Nazi.