Sunday, July 16, 2023

The Morning the Sky Melted—Robert Oppenheimer and a Test Called Trinity

                                A poster for the widely anticipated new film Oppenheimer.

The story of Robert Oppenheimer, the development of the Atomic Bomb, and his downfall has long fascinated story tellers across media.  That interest is bubbling over again with the widely anticipated release of a new film, Oppenheimer, which will open in American cinemas on July 21.  Directed by Christopher Nolan it stars Cillian Murphy in the title role, Emily Blunt as the scientists wife, Matt Damon  as General Leslie Groves, and Robert Downey Jr. as Lewis Strauss.

The story has also been told in American Prometheus: The Triumph and Tragedy of J. Robert Oppenheimer (2005) by Kai Bird and Martin J. Sherwin, which won the Pulitzer Prize for Biography for 2006; The 1980 BBC TV serial Oppenheimer, starring Sam Waterston which won three BAFTA Television Awards; The Day After Trinity, a 1980 documentary about Oppenheimer and the building of the atomic bomb, was nominated for an Academy Award and received a Peabody Award; Tom Morton-Smiths 2015 play Oppenheimer; in the 1989 film Fat Man and Little Boy, where he was portrayed by Dwight Schultz; and also in 1989, David Strathairn portrayed Oppenheimer in the made-for-TV movie Day One.

The now familiar mushroom cloud began to rise seconds after the detonation of the test device in the New Mexico desert.

They called it the Trinity Test.  To General Leslie Groves, the Army Engineer in overall charge of the Manhattan Project, the name was useful because it was so “generic” that should enemy intelligence services catch wind of it there would be no clue as to what was actually taking place.  But the chief scientist overseeing the operation, J. Robert Oppenheimer, picked the name for a more poetic reason.  The secularized Jew was inspired in some way by the mystical poetry of John Donne particularly the line “Batter my heart, three person’d God.”  Perhaps it also referenced an imponderable mystery.

At any rate at exactly 5:29:45 AM on July 16, 1945 at a secret desert test site at the Alamogordo Bombing Range in New Mexico the first Atomic Bomb in history was detonated.  In an instant the world changed forever.

The Manhattan Project has been described as the largest and most complex engineering and industrial undertaking in the history of the world to that point.  It was set off by a personal, somewhat anguished, letter by Albert Einstein, who considered himself a pacifist, to President Franklin D. Roosevelt making clear his belief that atomic weapons were not only feasible but would inevitably be built.  Intelligence indicated that Nazi scientists were at work on it in Germany.

 

 Major General Leslie R. Groves of the Corps of Engineers commanded the Manhattan Project.

The Manhattan Project under General Groves got under way in 1942.  The race was on.  Installations in support of the project soon spread across the continent. Basic research and development were conducted by Enrico Fermi and others at the University of Chicago and at the Argonne National Laboratories. Weapons development at the Los Alamos Laboratory in New Mexico was fed by other facilities, including Oak Ridge, Tennessee where uranium-235 was separated. Critical separation and production of plutonium-239 was done at the first large scale atomic reactor built at Hanford, Washington.  

The latter was particularly important because the cyclotrons were unable to produce enough pure plutonium to build more than one theoretically simple gun assembly type bomb.  The presence of trace amounts of plutonium-240 in the Hanford product was a challenge to designers because it undergoes spontaneous fission at an appreciable rate, and that releases excess thermal neutrons that could cause a devise to fizzleincompletely detonate and release unconsumed plutonium.  Teams were working on various approaches to the problem.  In the end it was decided not to test the gun assembly bomb before deployment.  Scientists were confident it would work and there was an extremely limited supply of pure plutonium

The Trinity test involved an implosion assembly device nicknamed The Gadget.  A small spherical plutonium core was surrounded by nearly nine tons of high explosives, detonated simultaneously at many points around the periphery of the bomb, causing a lensing effect that focused more and more explosive force towards the plutonium core. The force of the explosions would reduce the diameter of this plutonium core increasing its density to produce a critical mass of plutonium leading to an atomic detonation.  There was a great deal of uncertainty about whether this would work, hence the test. 

Scientists and engineers set up a betting pool on the possible results of the test.   Choices ranged from a complete dud through the destruction of all of New Mexico, to a doomsday event—the ignition of the atmosphere and incineration of the planet.  

Robert Oppenheimer--a scientist with the soul of a poet would be tormented by his creation and persecuted by the government he had served.

The device was hoisted to the top of a 100 foot tall steel tower to mimic the air detonation of a bomb dropped from an aircraft.  Two bunkers were set up to observe the test. Oppenheimer and other scientists occupied the bunker closest to the detonation site, about ten miles away.  General Groves and others watched from the second 17 miles away.  The test was originally set to go off at 4 am but thunder showers pushed that back an hour.

When it went off, the blast exploded with energy to around 20 kilotons of TNT.  The flash illuminated the dark desert as if it were daylight and could be seen for hundreds of miles.  It took the powerful blast traveling at the speed of sound took about 40 seconds to shake the first observation bunker and could eventually be felt over a hundred miles away.  In seconds a giant, and now familiar, mushroom cloud was growing which eventually reached a height of 7.2 miles in the atmosphere.  The blast crater was 10 feet deep and 1,100 feet wide and turned the desert sand into radioactive glass

                      Robert Oppenheimer and General Groves examine ground zero after the test.

The test was a success.  General Groves informed President Harry Truman who would soon authorize the use of atomic weapons against Japan.  On August 6 the untested gun assembly bomb, Little Boy, was dropped on Hiroshima.  It worked.  Three days later Fat Man, based on the Trinity test design, was ignited over Nagasaki. 

The ruins of a temple in Nagasaki after the city was destroyed by a bomb based on the design tested at the Alamogordo Bombing Range in New Mexico.

Sometime after the original test Oppenheimer wrote that it reminded him of line from the Hindu scripture the Bhagavd Gita, Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds.”

During the post-war Red scare he was investigated for his early opposition to the development of a thermonuclear weapon, pre-war association with members of the Communist Party including his brother, and allegations that he was a Soviet agent.  Disgraced and humiliated he was stripped of his security clearance and frozen out of any official role in the development, use, and deployment of nuclear weapons.  Despite being shunned by some institutions, Oppenheimer continued to lecture internationally, write, and encourage responsible and ethical science through several organizations.

President Lyndon B. Johnson presented the Enrico Fermi Award to Oppenheimer in 1963

In 1963 President John F. Kennedy offered a sign of official rehabilitation by awarding him the Enrico Fermi Award for lifetime achievement in the development, use, or production of energy.  Lyndon B. Johnson actually presented the gold medal just days after Kennedy was assassinated.

Oppenheimer died of throat cancer at his home in Princeton, New Jersey, on February 18, aged 62.

After the fall of the Soviet Union official declassified documents released by Russia showed the Oppenheimer was never an agent or asset and that he rebuffed attempts to recruit him.  In the U.S. no record was ever found that he was ever a member of the Communist Party despite claims by former FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover.

 

No comments:

Post a Comment