Showing posts with label Adrienne Rich. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Adrienne Rich. Show all posts

Thursday, March 26, 2026

Remembering Prophetic Feminist Poet Adrienne Rich

Adrienne Rich as a young poet.

Adrienne Rich was 82 when she died on March 26, 2012 in California, a long way from the life of privilege and learning into which she was born in Baltimore on May 16, 1929.   

Her father was a noted professor of medicine at prestigious Johns Hopkins and her mother had been a concert pianist.  He was a secular Jew, she a lady-like Southern Protestant.  Adrienne and her sisters were raised as nominal Christians.

Both parents cherished learning.  Before she was of kindergarten age Adrienne was reading from their vast library, mostly English poets.  Not trusting their bright children to a drab public education, Adrienne and her sisters were educated at home in that library until the fourth grade.  In her later years she was sent to a prestigious girl’s school, Roland Park Country School, which she later credited with providing “fine role models of single women who were intellectually impassioned.”

The progression to Radcliff College for her undergraduate degree was a natural one and she continued to flourish in the all-women environment.  She also took classes, mostly in poetry, at very male Harvard.  Her very first collection of poetry, A Change of World, was written as an undergraduate, selected by none other than W.H. Auden for publication as the Yale Younger Poets Award winner.  Auden wrote a thoughtful introduction lauding her technical competence, craftsmanship, and “…elegance and simple and precise phrasing.”

Thus, impressively launched on a noteworthy literary career she traveled to Europe on a Guggenheim Fellowship in 1952.  Part way into the year she abandoned formal study to linger in Italy.


Adrienne Rich's husband economist Alfred H. Conrad n 1959.

On returning to the United States in 1953 Rich married Harvard economist Alfred H. Conrad and settled into the life of an academic wife in Cambridge, Massachusetts.  Her first child, David, was born in 1955, the same years as her second collection, The Diamond Cutters and Other Poems, earned praise and garnered awards.  Two more sons were born and she struggled to balance the demands of marriage, motherhood, and writing.  She felt a failure at all of it.

Despite continuing to publish successfully, Rich could have been the model of the kind of accomplished, highly educated woman stifled by conventional domesticity that Betty Friedan wrote about in Feminine Mystique.

The themes began to emerge more forcefully in her poetry.  She abandoned the carefully crafted lines of metered rhyme which characterized her earlier work and began to work in blank verse.  The poems became more frankly autobiographical.  Snapshots of a Daughter-In-Law in 1963 delved into that struggle followed in 1966 with Necessities of Life.

 

Rich in the '60s--fierce and feminist.

Now both a recognized literary superstar and open feminist, Rich’s career began to eclipse that of her husband.  He moved with her to New York City when she accepted a post at Swarthmore.  She latter also taught in the Graduate School of Columbia University and a free style “open university” at the City Colleges of New York.  During this period, she became deeply and publicly involved not only in the feminist movement, but in opposition to the Vietnam War, and moved in increasingly leftist circles.  She hosted events for the Black Panthers and was a noteworthy signatory of the Writers and Editors War Tax Protest pledge, vowing to refuse tax payments in protest to the war.

Her poems were now overtly political.  The publication of Leaflets, an examination of the turmoil of the 1960’s, secured Rich’s place as a leading radical voice.

All of this placed a strain on her marriage.   He husband felt she was literally losing her mind and moved out.  He was quite wrong.  Rich hadn’t lost her mind but had decided to become the quintessential class traitor.  Three months after the separation Alfred Conrad shot and killed himself.  It was a naturally traumatic event for Rich and her children.

 

A cartoon by Alison Bechdel demonstrates the enormous influence Rich had on many women writers and artists.

Yet the accolades and awards continued to pile up. There was the Eunice Tietjens Memorial Prize from Poetry Magazine, the Shelley Memorial Award from the Poetry Society of America, another Guggenheim Fellowship, and various prestigious academic appointments.

She reached perhaps the pinnacle of her literary career with the publication in 1973 of Diving into the Wreck. It was her most intensely personal work yet, anguished and angry yet clear of thought and expression.  She was picked to share the National Book Award in Poetry with Allan Ginsberg in 1974 but declined to accept it as an individual. Instead, she made national headlines by going to the podium with Alice Walker and Audre Lorde to accept the award on behalf of all women writers. 

Rich’s life and work changed dramatically in 1976 when she began her life-long relationship with Jamaican-born novelist and editor Michelle Cliff.  She later said that her lesbianism was both the natural fulfillment of desires and yearnings suppressed since girl’s school and a political statement.  Her writing began to express this new life, both philosophically in works like Of Woman Born: Motherhood as Experience and Institution, her first significant prose work, and lyrical frankly erotic verse in the pamphlet Twenty-One Love Poems.

 

                                   Michelle Cliff became Rich's life partner, inspiration, and collaborator.

She continued to hold important teaching posts at Rutgers, Scripps College of San Jose State University, and Cornell.  She dedicated more time to essays, literary criticism, and political theory, publishing several well received books.

Rich and Cliff settled in California and co-edited an important Lesbian journal, Sinister Wisdom in 1981.  She published three more books of poetry in the 1980s and garnered more literary awards—the Ruth Paul Lilly Poetry Prize in 1986, the Elmer Holmes Bobst Award in Arts and Letters from NYU, and the National Poetry Association Award for Distinguished Service to the Art of Poetry both in 1989.

A revived interest in her Jewish identity and what it means to be a leftist Jew led her to found. Bridges: A Journal for Jewish Feminists and Our Friends in 1990.

An Atlas of the Difficult World, published in 1991, won the Los Angeles Times Book Award in Poetry, and the Lenore Marshall/Nation Award, Commonwealth Award in Literature as well as the Poet’s Prize in 1993.  In 1994 she tagged for a MacArthur Foundation “genius grant.” All the while she served in mentoring positions to women writers around the world.

In 1997 Rich made headlines by publicly snubbing the National Medal of Arts in protest to a House of Representatives vote to end the National Endowment for the Arts and policies of the Clinton Administration.  She told reporters “I could not accept such an award from President Clinton or this White House because the very meaning of art, as I understand it, is incompatible with the cynical politics of this administration... [Art] means nothing if it simply decorates the dinner table of the power which holds it hostage.”

In the new century Rich was slowed by advancing rheumatoid arthritis but continued to speak out publicly, especially against the looming war in Iraq. 

 

Adrienne Rich--the elder still untamed.

She was named a Chancellor of the Board of the Academy of American Poets in 2004.  That decade she produced four more collections of poetry, the last being Tonight No Poetry Will Serve: Poems 2007-2010 and three more collections of essays. 

In 2006 she was awarded the National Book Foundation Medal for Distinguished Contribution to American Letters followed in 2010 with the Lifetime Recognition Award from the Griffin Poetry Prize. 

That’s more than enough official honors for anyone.  But Adrienne Rich’s legacy cannot be measured in plaques, certificates, and engraved bowls.  It is in the hearts of all the readers whose lives she touched and enriched, all the students she nurtured, all the writers she encouraged.

 

What Kind of Times Are These

 

There’s a place between two stands of trees where the grass grows uphill

and the old revolutionary road breaks off into shadows

near a meeting-house abandoned by the persecuted

who disappeared into those shadows.

 

I’ve walked there picking mushrooms at the edge of dread, but don’t be fooled

this isn’t a Russian poem, this is not somewhere else but here,

our country moving closer to its own truth and dread,

its own ways of making people disappear.

 

I won't tell you where the place is, the dark mesh of the woods

meeting the unmarked strip of light—

ghost-ridden crossroads, leafmold paradise:

I know already who wants to buy it, sell it, make it disappear.

 

And I won’t tell you where it is, so why do I tell you

anything?  Because you still listen, because in times like these

to have you listen at all, it’s necessary

to talk about trees.

 

—Adrienne Rich

 

Wednesday, April 6, 2022

Poetry that Sizzles About Frying the Rosenbergs—National Poetry Month 2022

Ethel and Julius Rosenberg are escorted by Federal Marshals to their trial on March 21, 1950.  On April 5, both were sentenced to die.

On April 5, 1951 Julius and Ethel Rosenberg were sentenced to death for nuclear espionage.  There was never much doubt that Julius, an electrical engineer, had been a Soviet agent since at least 1942 when he was in the Army Signal Corps at the Engineering Laboratories at Fort Monmouth, New Jersey.  During that time, he passed on secret research on electronics, communications, radar, and guided missile controls to the Soviets, then American Allies against the Nazis.  Julius was fired in 1945 when his pre-war membership in the Communist Party surfaced but remained an intelligence agent charged with building a spy network with particular interest in the super secret development of the atomic bomb.

The extent of his wife Ethel’s involvement in all of this was open to question.  Some believed she was completely innocent and had been duped by her husband.  Others believed she was marginally involved as a sometimes courier and errand runner.  The most damning accusation was simply that she typed up some notes on the development of the implosion-type atomic bomb—the Fat Man bomb dropped on Nagasaki.  But she did connect her husband to her brother in law David Greenglass who was working on the top-secret Manhattan Project at the Los Alamos National Laboratory in New Mexico. 

When Greenglass was arrested for stealing atomic secrets, he implicated his brother in law saying he had passed documents to him on a Manhattan Street Corner.  Shortly before the Rosenbergs went on trial Greenglass and his wife Ruth, Ethel’s sister, suddenly changed their story and claimed that the information had been passed in the Rosenberg apartment and they had watched Ethel type up Greenglass’s handwritten notes.  That was enough for Federal prosecutors to seek the death penalty for Ethel as well as her husband.

Ethel, the mother of two young sons, was always a more sympathetic character than her husband even as she loyally stood by his side.  Not only did she refuse to testify against him, but she echoed his stand on the Fifth Amendment against self-incrimination and refusal to either acknowledge membership in the Communist Party or name Party associates and/or other members of the spy ring.  Her participation still seemed so limited that almost no one expected that she would receive the death penalty.  And yet she did.

Deputy Attorney General William P. Rogers later said that the death sentence was imposed on Ethel in an effort to extract a full confession from Julius, but “She called our bluff.” 

There may have also been the subtle effects or anti-Semitism—or the fear of stirring up anti-Semitism during the already superheated hysteria of the Post-war Red Scare.  Both the prosecutor, U.S. Attorney Irving Saypol and Judge Irving Kaufman were Jewish.  Another rising young Federal prosecutor, Roy Cohn, soon to be notorious as the ruthless chief council to Senator Joseph McCarthy, claimed that he had influence over both men and convinced them that unless both were found guilty and given the maximum sentence a wave of anti-Semitism would sweep the U.S. and fundamentally endanger Jews. Of course, Cohn was a notorious liar, and his account may not be reliable.

In this country outside of the besieged far left the Rosenbergs got little support.  Communists, “fellow travelers” and the labor left were all under heavy attack and the well-oiled defense committees with decades of experience in high profile cases were both overwhelmed with cases of persecution and themselves the targets of investigations and prosecutions.  The liberal American Civil Liberties Union was falling all over itself to get disentangled from the Communists and flatly refused to support defense efforts.  No major American Jewish organization including the Anti-Defamation League of B’nai B’rith spoke out for them and many publicly denounced them.  Only the most steadfastly loyal of the old Jewish Labor left, especially the New York needle trades kept up the motions of defense work.

Abroad defense of the Rosenbergs became an international cause celeb especially in France where leading intellectuals appeared a huge rallies like this one in Paris.

In Europe, especially France, where virtually the entire artistic and literary intelegencia was Marxist of one stripe or another, the Rosenbergs became a great cause celeb.  Charges that they were victims of anti-Semitism were widespread and their case was compared to the famous French travesty of justice, the Dreyfus Affair.  Jean-Paul Sartre scathingly wrote that the case was:

…a legal lynching which smears with blood a whole nation. By killing the Rosenbergs, you have quite simply tried to halt the progress of science by human sacrifice. Magic, witch-hunts, autos-da-fé, sacrifices—we are here getting to the point: your country is sick with fear ... you are afraid of the shadow of your own bomb.

International artists including Pablo Picasso, Frida Kahlo, Diego Rivera, and writers Nelson Algren, Bertolt Brecht, and Dashiell Hammett were all vocal in the defense movement.  Albert Einstein, who probably knew that the Rosenbergs had not given the Soviets anything of real value, lent his enormous prestige to the effort and staunchly anti-Communist Pope Pius XII even made a direct appeal to President Dwight Eisenhower for clemency.  Ike was unmoved.  He refused to intervene.

Julius and Ethel being electrocuted.  Ethel proved harder to kill.

Finally, after all appeals had been exhausted Julius and the Ethel were transferred to New York state’s Sing Sing prison because the Federal Bureau of Prisons no longer operated any means of execution.  On Friday June 19, 1953 at 8 pm—before sundown marked the beginning of the Jewish sabbath, Julius was strapped into the electric chair and died after the first jolt.  Ethel proved tougher.  Her heart was still beating after three shocks.  Two more needed to be applied after which witnesses saw a puff of smoke escape from her skull.

In retrospect, America turned out to be pretty queasy about executing a woman.  Ethel was, after all, the only the second woman ever executed by the Feds.  The other was Mary Surat whose Maryland inn had been used as a meeting place by John Wilks Booth and his accomplices in the plot to kill not only Abraham Lincoln but the Vice President and Secretaries of War and State.

As the Cold War dragged on and other high profile Soviet spies escaped the death penalty—some traded in spy swaps—the nagging suspicion that anti-Semitism may have played a part after all.  The Rosenbergs were the only spies executed.

By the early 1960’s legal scholars were swinging to the opinion that, as one put it, they were guilty, but lynched meaning that the evidence did not support the severe penalty and that there were several improprieties by the government in their rush to get the desired out-come.

The Rosenberg sons Michael and Robert were not kept sheltered from their parents' ordeal.  The experience became a life long obsession for both.

Meanwhile the Rosenberg’s two orphaned sons were adopted and raised by a sympathetic family.  When they grew up Michael and Robert Meeropol, spent years trying to prove their parent’s innocence including co-authoring the widely read We Are Your Sons: The Legacy of Ethel and Julius Rosenberg in 1975. 

After the fall of Communism in the Soviet Union, KGB files revealed that Julius Rosenberg was, indeed, at the center of a large and active espionage ring and that Ethel was rather marginally involved but aware of the activities.  But the sketches and notes on the Fat Boy bomb turned out to have little or no value to the Soviet atomic program. 

The sons now acknowledge that but maintain their parents did not deserve to die.  Robert wrote an additional memoir, An Execution in the Family: One Son’s Journey in 2003.  Michael’s daughter Ivy Meeropol directed a 2004 documentary about her grandparents, Heir to an Execution, which was featured at the Sundance Film Festival.

The case has been explored in several cultural media.  E.L. Doctorow’s 1971 novel The Book of Daniel was based on the case as seen through the eyes of a fictional son and was made into 1983 film Daniel.  Another novel, Robert Coover’s The Public Burning, also covered the case and was partially narrated by Richard Nixon.  In Tony Kushner’s Pulitzer Prize winning play Angels in America the ghost of Ethel Rosenberg haunts Roy Cohn, now a bitter repressed homosexual dying of AIDS.  The main character in Sylvia Plath’s novel, The Bell Jar, is morbidly fascinated with the Rosenberg case.  Bob Dylan wrote one of his early ballads about them.

A lithograph of Ethel and Julius Rosenburg made and signed by Pablo Picasso in 1952.

And many poets have also been inspired.  But we will start with Ethel herself, penned for her sons after being transferred to Sing Sing to await execution.

If We Die

 

            You shall know, my sons, shall know

            why we leave the song unsung,

            the book unread, the work undone

            to rest beneath the sod.

 

            Mourn no more, my sons, no more

            why the lies and smears were framed,

            the tears we shed, the hurt we bore

            to all shall be proclaimed.

 

            Earth shall smile, my sons, shall smile

            and green above our resting place,

            the killing end, the world rejoice

            in brotherhood and peace.

 

            Work and build, my sons, and build

            a monument to love and joy,

            to human worth, to faith we kept

            for you, my sons, for you.

 

—Ethel Rosenberg

Ossining. N.Y., January 24, 1953

 

I love this piece by a semi-anonymous high school student named Eileen from Troy, Michigan who contributing as Misseilli has had over 100 verses published in the online version of Teen Ink and several selected for their print editions.  I can see why.  I loved the poem but was taken aback by the reference to heaven, which did not seem to jibe with the Rosenbergs’ good Marxist atheism.  Then in my research for this blog entry and found the report of the puff of smoke over Ethel’s head at her execution.  Ah, Grasshopper, you are deeper than your years.

 

Rosenberg

 

The lightning tore through
The guilt and the shame,
Scorching the veins until
They were burnt black.
The fire serrated the lungs
But the heart stood whole
And ebbed the storm that
Ravaged the rosy brain.
Peace slipped through the
Pores and before she felt it,
They saw her soul rise from
Her skull and sway the
Empty steel rafters that hid
Heaven from men’s eyes.

 

—Misseilli

 

Adrienne Rich.

Adrienne Rich was 82 when she died in California in 2012, a long way from the life of privilege and learning into which she was born in Baltimore on May 16, 1929.   She had gone on to be one of the pioneering female voices of the Beats and a prophetic feminist voice, poet, and activist.  In For Ethel Rosenberg, she richly entwined personal memoir with the sacrifice of the woman who fascinates her.

For Ethel Rosenberg ·

convicted, with her husband, of “conspiracy to commit espionage”; killed in the electric chair June 19, 1953

 

Europe 1953:

throughout my random sleepwalk the words

scratched on walls, on pavements painted over railway arches Liberez les Rosenberg!

Escaping from home I found home everywhere:

the Jewish question, Communism

marriage itself

a question of loyalty or punishment

my Jewish father writing me letters of seventeen pages finely inscribed harangues

questions of loyalty and punishment

One week before my wedding

that couple gets the chair the volts grapple her, don't kill her fast enough

Liberez les Rosenberg!

I hadn’t realized

our family arguments were so important

my narrow understanding of crime of punishment

no language for this torment

 

mystery of that marriage always both faces

on every front page in the world

Something so shocking so unfathomable

it must be pushed aside

 

II

 

She sank however into my soul. A weight of sadness I hardly can register how deep

her memory has sunk that wife and mother

like so many

who seemed to get nothing out of any of it except her children

that daughter of a family like so many

needing its female monster

she, actually wishing to be an artist

wanting out of poverty possibly also really wanting

revolution

that woman strapped in the chair

no fear and no regrets

charged by posterity

not with selling secrets to the Communists but with wanting to distinguish herself  

being a bad daughter a bad mother

And I walking to my wedding

by the same token a bad daughter a bad sister my forces focused

on that hardly revolutionary effort Her life and death the possible ranges of disloyalty

so painful so unfathomable they must be pushed aside ignored for years

 

III

 

Her mother testifies against her Her brother testifies against her After her death

she becomes a natural prey for pornographers her death itself a scene

her body sizzling half strapped whipped like a sail

She becomes the extremist victim described nonetheless as rigid of will

what are her politics by then no one knows

Her figure sinks into my soul a drowned statue

sealed in lead

For years it has lain there unabsorbed first as part of that dead couple

on the front pages of the world the week

I gave myself in marriage

then slowly severing drifting apart a separate death a life unto itself

no longer the Rosenbergs

no longer the chosen scapegoat the family monster

till I hear how she sang a prostitute to sleep

in the Women's House of Detention

 

Ethel Greenglass Rosenberg would you have marched to take back the night collected signatures

for battered women who kill What would you have to tell us would you have burst the net

 

IV

 

Why do I even want to call her up

to console my pain (she feels no pain at all) why do I wish to put such questions

to ease myself (she feels no pain at all

she finally burned to death like so many) why all this exercise of hindsight?

Since if I imagine her at all I have to imagine first

the pain inflicted on her by women

her mother testifies against her

her sister-in-law testifies against her

and how she sees it

not the impersonal forces not the historical reasons why they might have hated her strength

If I have held her at arm’s length till now if I have still believed it was

my loyalty, my punishment at stake

if I dare imagine her surviving

I must be fair to what she must have lived through I must allow her to be at last

political in her ways not in mine

her urgencies perhaps impervious to me defining revolution as she defines it

or, bored to the marrow of her bones with “politics”

bored with the vast boredom of long pain

small; tiny in fact; in her late sixties liking her room her private life living alone perhaps

no one you could interview maybe filling a notebook herself with secrets she has never sold

—Adrienne Rich