Friday, December 5, 2014

Lift Every Voice and Cry…

A die-in at Grand Central Station in New York protesting the refusal to indict the cop who choked Eric Garner to death.

An old, stirring song written in 1900 by James Weldon Johnson and set to music by his brother John Rosamund Johnson began with the words “Lift every voice and sing.”  It was written at a moment in time when Black Americans were under incredible pressure.  Almost all of the gains save the abolition of chattel slavery had been erased by the imposition of Jim Crow laws in the states of the old Confederacy and in border states as well.  In the North de facto segregation worked just as well as that imposed by law in hemming in the opportunities for most people of color.  Yet the song was a hopeful anthem.  It was first performed on Lincoln’s Birthday in honor of a speech to be given by the apostle of boot-strap racial self-improvement by education Booker T. Washington at a segregated school in Jacksonville, Florida.  It would be widely popularized by the Fisk Singers, the traveling choir from Nashville’s Fisk University, then the most prestigious Black college in the country.  It was a song that spoke for the dreams and aspirations of a sliver of the Black population—a tiny, educated elite that felt it must lift the whole race on its shoulders.
The song became known far and wide as the Black National Anthem and continued to be sung through the Civil Rights campaigns of the 1950’s and ‘60’s alongside earthier, more militant songs rooted more in Black gospel and blues and less on European choral traditions.
Much has changed since those hopeful words were first voiced.  Hard won victories smashed Jim Crow.  Voting rights were won at a painful cost in blood and tears.  The election of a Black man as President of the United States was heralded by some as the inauguration of a new, supposedly post-racial era. 
How quickly those gains have been eroded or shown to be illusionary.  That Black President in no time became the focus of rage for many whites many of whom barely understood that the root of their anger was the fear of losing privilege and its racial motivation.  A greater percent of children, North and South, are in segregated public schools today than in 1950.  Blacks lost more jobs in the Great Recession than any other racial or ethnic group, have recovered fewer of them, and have lost the most real income collapsing much of what had been a fragile Black middle class.  Most shockingly of all, a fifth of all adult black men at any time are incarcerated and more than half will be jailed in their lifetimes.  Police departments, largely White but including many Blacks, have become occupation armies whose primary function is the protection of White property and the preservation of systematic dominance.  The rule of an oligarchic elite—the 1% in the term popularized by the Occupy movement—survives by exploiting fear of supposedly animalistic Black violence to prevent almost equally disenfranchised and marginalized Whites, Latinos, Native American, and Asians from uniting with Blacks.
All of this has come to a head with a string of ugly police murders of unarmed Black males with seeming impunity.  You know the drill—Michael Brown in Ferguson, Missouri; 12 year old Tamir Rice killed for playing with a toy pistol just two seconds after the arrival of a White cop; and Eric Garner a very large Black man who may have been guilty—gasp!—of making some spare change by selling individual cigarettes to the desperate who was swarmed by police and wrestled to the ground by an illegal choke hold as he gasped, “I can’t breathe!”  In the first and last cases grand juries refused to indict the killer cop setting off nation-wide demonstrations.  In the case of young Rice absolutely nobody expects a different result.  And these are not isolated instances, but just egregious examples of police killing that have been repeated scores of time around the country every year.  More than 500 American citizens are killed by our own police every year—a hefty majority of whom are Black males, some unarmed, and many other in questionable circumstances.
The reactions to these events have divided the nation.  Black almost unanimously are outraged and hurt.  They are becoming more willing to confront the violent oppression on the streets which is a daily part of their lives.  Many Whites reflexively believe that any police action against Blacks is somehow justified.  Even many White liberals who annually celebrate Martin Luther King Day, who would never dream of uttering the N word, and who like to congratulate themselves on being colorblind cannot grasp that these killings are part and parcel of deeply ingrained racial animus.  They are taking affront by being accused benefiting from White skin privilege.  

I understand.  No one wants their virtuous self-image called into question.  After all, they say, I never owned a slave or oppressed a Black person.  Quite seriously more times than you think possible the next assertion is actually “some of my best friends are Black.”  Talk of White skin privilege sound like an accusation of personal racism.  And it is especially hard for those who may have come from less privileged background themselves to hear.
We will leave aside for the moment the even harder notion that society is so deeply saturated with racism that even the most enlightened and well-meaning of us have absorbed its assumptions and act on them every day.  And none of those assumptions is more deeply and viscerally held than fear of Black men.  This leads a lot White folks to say stupid thing when discussing these incidents, most frequently by trying to find some reason of individual behavior in each case that invited or caused a rationally violent response by the police.
Look I understand.  This well-meaning White guy with an actual history of working for and supporting Civil Rights is just as apt to fall into these traps as anyone else.  May be more so.  I can always bring out my I-marched-with-Martin-Luther-King trump card. 
But when I take the hard moment to look in the ugly mirror of reality I come upon some brutal reminders.  In my youth I was often in the streets taking part in demonstrations against the Vietnam War—think the ’68 Democratic Convention.  Things got hairy at times.  I dodged tear gas and police batons.  But in my worst moments I never for a moment believed that I might be shot, not even when the National Guard with Jeep mounted machine guns came rumbling down Michigan Avenue.  Yet in the very same city earlier in the very same year Mayor Richard J. Daley had issued his famous shoot to kill order against Black rioters.  The West Side became an actual war zone with the Black corpses to prove it.
Even in my later years I have led or participated in noisy and semi-raucous small demonstrations out here in the boonies of McHenry County touching on some hot-button emotional issues like immigration and marriage equality.  But my mostly White cohorts and I never drew more than a couple of polite police officers who mostly stayed out of our way and let us do our thing.  But a similar demonstration in size and noise by Black folk in many American cities and town would be more than enough to bring out the SWAT Teams, the armored vehicles, and phalanxes of cops arrayed for war.  Our demonstrations ended with us finishing up at the appointed hour and going home.  Black demonstrations might well end in tear gas, police charges, and mass arrests.  The media, if they took note of us would describe us as demonstrators.  They would describe the Blacks as a rowdy mob or rioters.
I’m a working class guy and often more than a little scruffy around the edges with my beat-up old hats, scraggly too-long hair, untamed goatee, and seedy, often second hand clothing.  I could pass for any homeless dude.  I know what it’s like to have a cop slow down as her rolls by when I am walking down some residential street.  I have been stopped for questioning walking home late from a second shift job.  As insulting and inconvenient as it is, I know that I just have to present some identification and politely explain that my house “is just over there” officer to be sent on my way—sometimes even with an apology.  Walking while Black in McHenry County, on the other hand is a good way to get stopped, frisked, and thrown into the back of a squad car.
When my oldest grandson Nicholas was in high school he lived with us.  He was tall and skinny with thick red hair down to the middle of his back.  He took to wearing all black including in cool weather an overcoat that made people think of Columbine school shooting Trench Coat Mafia and baggy jeans festooned with five pounds of chains.  He and his pals—we called them his posse—were into fantasy roll playing games.  Nick would roam the neighborhood with a five foot long reproduction English double-bladed broadsword.  It was not sharpened, but quite heavy and if swung with enough power could, I’m sure, separate an arm from a shoulder or get a head half-way off a neck.  His friends carried a variety of swords, sabers, dirks and the like, some of them quite real.  One even had a spiked mace on a chain.  I’m sure they were a terrifying sight.  A couple of times local cops stopped him and told him to “take it home.” 
Now try calculating the expected life span of a Black teenage boy under the identical circumstances.  Go ahead. It won’t take long to realize that he would be riddled with bullets long before he ever had a chance to explain that he was only playing a game.
I get the point.  You get the point.  All of this is only the tip of the iceberg of white skin privilege when it comes to our contacts with the police.
Some White folk are learning to face this reality, as bitter a pill as it may be.  The demonstrations around Ferguson and the Eric Garner case have included lots of White folks.  Members of various religious communities have taken lead rolls.  I am proud to say that my Unitarian Universalists have been there and done that.  Our ministers are, by in large, doing a good job at talking to their congregations about it.
But even notoriously liberal do-gooding UUs are not immune from either denial or of finding ways to justify police actions and the willful acts of society to refuse to punish obvious criminal behavior.  The Rev. Victoria Weinstein writing in her highly respected blog PeaceBang notes that many of her colleagues have received push back from resentful congregants.  She wrote:
The denial is staggering. My colleagues are weighing in, one by one and then in a rush, commenting on Facebook and e-mails and in messages about their conversations with white parishioners who don’t get it, who are sunk up to their knees like quicksand in white privilege and denial and a worldview that wants to assume that this doesn’t just happen and he must have done something and you don’t know everything and did you read the report? and did you read it as thoroughly as I did, because if you did you wouldn’t be so upset, you wouldn’t be sick and snarling and enraged and disgusted with humanity right now, you’d be the nice, comforting minister I expect you to be.
It’s tough.  I know. And exhausting.  I refrained since last summer from weighing in.  I told myself that others were saying what I would say and they are saying it better.  Who needs my voice?  And I don’t want to become a nuisance or a nag.  And I am just a two-bit blogger with a tiny following.  

But the time for silence is past, if it was ever appropriate.  Dr. King used to go on about how the silence of the good empowered evil.  He said it half a dozen different ways at different times.  He knew what he was talking about.
We, White folks who have finally grown tired of violence and oppression in our name need our own Anthem now.  Perhaps we could call it Lift Every Voice and Cry.  Perhaps it would inspire us to speak out, to march, and, yes, just to listen.
This is my cry.  


  1. I haven't finished it yet, but the number of deaths at the hands of US police is far higher than the FBI count (they only count 'justified' murder).

  2. I'd like to put in a comment if I may. "Black lives matter" ?

    All lives matter.

    I am Sicilian. My family moved to America only a short 3 generations ago and yet I have been quite abused, being called a white and being accused of "my people" having caused such atrocities to the people of color and have had my fair share of being the devil.

    But they forget what they did to my people.

    Sicily has had a long history of being conquered. We have been conquered by everyone including Africa who has changed Sicilian culture the most!

    Think before you call just anyone who is not the same skin tone as you names.

  3. Experiment 813--Your knee is jerking so high I am pretty sure you did not actually read the article. If you had you might have noticed that one was called any names. White folks, myself included, were described as having "white skin privilage whether they know it or not. I sited numerous concrete examples of how that works. Some of us have come to support the Black Lives Matter movement not because we don't believe tha "all lives matter" but because our society and culture has clearly not acted as if the lives of Black Americans have the same worth and value as those of white Americans. To deny the right to point that out is like telling someone raising money to end cancer to shut up because "all diseases matter."